You can also connect with us on:
Leadership Solutions: Executive Coaching and Leadership Development specializing in Strategy Development and Implementation
  • Home
  • About
  • Coaching
    • Coaching Offer!
    • How I work and why you should work with me
    • The Benefits of Coaching
    • Effective Teams
    • Executive Coaching
    • Coaching and Mentoring: Developing Managers as Coaches & Mentors
    • Difficult Team Conversations
    • Choosing a Coach
  • Strategy
    • What is Strategy? >
      • What it takes to make a good Strategy
      • Diagnosing the internal environment
      • Figuring Out How to Reach the Promised Land
      • Strategy: External Analysis
      • The Competitive Environment
      • Defining the Challenge and Creating the Guiding Policy
      • WIGs, Scoreboards and Tracking Progress
    • Strategic Leadership >
      • Strategic Thinking
      • Strategic Thinking (cont.)
      • Strategic Acting
      • Strategic Acting (cont.)
      • Strategic Acting (cont.)
      • Strategic Influencing
      • Strategic Influencing (cont.)
      • Strategic Influencing (cont.)
      • Strategic Leadership Teams
      • Strategy as a Learnining Process
      • Summing Up Strategic Leadership
    • Strategic Thinking >
      • What is Strategic Thinking?
      • Strategic Thinking as a Discipline
      • Where to Play and How to Win
      • Bucking an Industry Norm
      • Replicating Pockets of Excellence
      • Questions about Strategic Thinking
  • Leadership
    • Developing Business Leaders
    • Personality and Business
    • Self-Leadership >
      • Selling when you are not a Sales Person
      • Meetings! Bloody Meetings! Be Mindful
      • Resilience. How Resilient are You?
      • Resilience: Build your Own
      • Build Your Team's Resilience
    • Leadership >
      • #UselessLosers
      • Leadership is Exercised One Conversation at a Time
      • Presenteeism - Doing more harm than good
      • 5 Steps to Develop your Leadership Skills
    • Culture Change
  • Clients
    • What Our Clients Say >
      • What a Massive Shift
      • Our small part in the fight against Corruption
  • Articles
  • Contact

The Art of the Review

11/3/2020

0 Comments

 
It is so easy to get bogged down in the busyness and stress of life and work and lose sight of how effective and impactful we have been. I'm writing this in November of 2020 - a year that has profoundly impacted everyone. Nothing was as we expected; little was as it seemed; much was completely out of our control. For many it was a brutal year filled with setbacks; for some it was replete with opportunities, but no less brutal.

I have just returned from a most welcome short holiday in the mountains, where I love to walk, take in the sunshine, swim in mountain streams and spend time with loved ones. 
Those hours of walking gave me pause to think about 2020 and to review what happened and how effective I have been. My personal review is not the topic for this article. Believe me! It is a mixed bag! This is more about the art of the review.

I call it art in the same sense as my previous article "The Art of Conversation". A review is also a kind of conversation, even if you are doing a personal review. The best and most flexible process for a review is one I came across in a book called "On Being a Supervisee: Creating Learning Partnerships". The authors, Michael Carroll and Maria C. Gilbert, quote a review process used by the American military called the After Action Review - or AAR. After any military operation, small groups of soldiers gather with their commanders. The basic ground rules are that:
1. Nobody will be penalised in any way for anything they contribute to the discussion;
2. No blame or fault is acceptable.

The discussion has 6 questions:
1. What did we set out to do?
2. What happened?
3. What worked/went well?
4. What didn't work/went badly?
5. What have we learned?
6. What will we do differently next time?

These 6 questions can be used in slightly different wording across a wide range of situations. Here are some examples:

A. Project/Strategic Review
1. What were our goals?
2. What did we achieve? What actually happened?
3. What worked/went well?
4. What didn't?
5. What have we learned?
6. What do we need to do now?

B. Progress Review (on a Project or Strategy)
1. What are we trying to achieve?
2. What is actually happening? What progress have we made?
3. What have we done well?
4. What have we not done well?
5. What lessons must be learned?
6. What do we need to do now (to get things back on track)?

C. Personal Review
1. What were my goals for this year?
2. What have I achieved? (And what have I not achieved?)
3. What did I do well?
4. What did I not do well?
5. What have I learned?
6. What am I going to do now/What are my new goals?

D. Performance Review
No matter what the admin process is around formal performance reviews, the actual conversation is along the same lines:
1. What did you set out to achieve in the last x months?
2. What did you actually do?
3. What went well?
4. What did not go well?
5. What have you learned?
6. What do you want to do now? PLUS And how can I support you?

I have used this process in various contexts many many times and have never failed to be enthused by how inspiring and rewarding it has been for the participants. I love that the questions are asked in a way that does not brook blame or fault. When people know that the purpose of the review is to learn rather than to apportion blame, they are willing to be quite frank about their experiences - and this is how one creates a learning organisation. Simple! Not necessarily easy though.

0 Comments

    Categories

    All
    20Plenty
    Accountability & Responsibility
    Coach
    Coaching
    #coaching
    Conversation
    CPD (Continuing Professional Development)
    Culture
    Culture Change
    Diversity
    Employeeengagement
    Employee Engagement
    Employee Survey
    Engagement
    Ethics & Ethical Dilemmas
    #goals
    Influence
    Inspiration
    Leaders As Coaches
    Leadership
    #leadership
    Leadership Development
    Leadership Skills
    Management
    #management
    Managers
    Managers As Coaches
    Managers-as-coaches
    Motivation
    Performance
    Personal Leadership
    Planning
    Relationships
    Relationships Matter
    Resilience
    Rules Of Engagement
    Self-awareness
    Self Care
    Self Leadership
    Self-Leadership
    Servant Leadership
    Strategic Leadership
    #success
    Team_resilience
    Teams
    The Discipline Of Leadership
    Trust & Trustworthiness
    Values
    Vision

    Archives

    March 2021
    February 2021
    January 2021
    November 2020
    October 2020
    September 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    January 2020
    October 2019
    September 2019
    May 2019
    March 2019
    January 2019
    February 2018
    April 2017
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    May 2015

    RSS Feed

Whats Next?

Leadership Development
Executive Coaching
Business Strategy

What my clients say

Articles
    Work We've Done
    Self-leadership
    Strategic Leadership
    Strategic Thinking
    Strategy

Call me! 082 5519504
Picture
Picture
Picture

    What improvements or changes do you seek?

Submit